Forums


SearchForum Home
  Aggregated  The church in formation  General  Resistance to S...
 Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 
 11/11/2006 6:34:29 AM
User is offlineBCOwen
5 posts


Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 (United States) Modified By webmaster  on 11/10/2006 11:30:27 PM)

I just read Steve Porter's article "Sancitification in a New Key: Relieving Evangelical Anxieties Over Spiritual Formation."  In this article, he identifies the some of individuals (Willard, Foster, etc), emphases, and practices (spiritaul direction, solitude, etc.) that are becoming the target of concerned evangelicals. 

Is anyone encountering significant resistance as they attempt to bring the insights of spiritual formation into their local church?  If so, how has the resistance been addressed?  My church is in the process of bringing some of this thinking into our church body and I'd appreciate hearing from anyone regarding their success and failure in this area.

 11/27/2006 7:10:19 PM
User is offlineIn His Grip
4 posts


Re: Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 (United States)
The Evangelical church can run the gammot from fear to resistance.  Some in the church are so fearful of leaving the straight and narrow that anything that is foreign to our understanding automatically gets rejected.   Oue comfort level  is often tied to our having the  answers.  We like to have the right answer to the right questions.  A new thought can sometimes rattle our catagories.

The Evangelical church is good at labelling and if one is using language that smacks of "experience" or "mystery" or "presence" then we get labeled as our there and the caution sign gets raised.

I am an evangelical with a love for the word.  I seek to be grounded and rooted in the word but I also long for the reality of His presence that moves beyond the head knowlege to congruence.

In His Grip
 5/6/2007 4:21:52 AM
User is offlinedrimoldi
5 posts


Re: Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 (N/A)

Yeah, in my church we have experienced concern to people actually leaving the church because we are bringing some of these forms into our church.  I have given out Porter's article along with some others and have found they have help sooth some fears.  I have taken many through small group experiences in Spiritual Formation with mixed results.  Many have felt encouraged or have sensed real growth as a result.  Others have felt uncomfortable with the "experiential form" of the exercises or direction.  I think the biggest concern I am hearing from conservative evangelicals is that this form of discipleship is linked to the Emergent Church, which has been branded negatively.  Let me know what you thoughts are.

 7/17/2007 5:02:18 PM
User is offlinepbowman
3 posts


Re: Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 (N/A)
First of all, thanks for the article I look forward to reading it! 

Only recently have I begun to encounter some slight resistance and hesitancy to some of the "new" ideas that I've presented for our church.  These include things like contemplative prayer and practicing the Christian year. 

So far the resistance has come in two forms.  One is the fear that these things are "new age".  The other that they are too "Catholic" (sorry to any Catholics here, a lot of people in our church have had negative experiences and unfortunately can be quite anti-Catholic).

With these resistances, my approach has been to try and educate and inform.  It seems that a lot of people have a wrong idea about spiritual disciplines and then they go read stuff on the Internet that tells them spiritual formation is new age.  So a proper education of what the disciplines are and how they are to be used is in need.  People are afraid of becoming legalistic so they shun any idea of ritual or disciplined practices. 

Honestly, it's been a little tough for me to take encounter these resistances, I tend to take it personal.  So, one word of advice, don't take it personal!! :)  Just be ready to educate and fully explain (using the language they are familiar with) where you are coming from and what you are hoping to accomplish.
 3/17/2008 1:26:28 AM
User is offlinecathysfiddle
1 posts


Re: Resistance to Spiritual Formation
 (N/A)

Sigh. It seems that at my church, if Lifeway didn't publish it, it's heresy. I never thought I'd be doing it, but I find myself church-shopping.

  Aggregated  The church in formation  General  Resistance to S...